Horst Bartel

Horst Bartel (16 January 1928 – 22 June 1984) was a German historian^[1] and university professor. He was involved in most of the core historiography projects undertaken in the German Democratic Republic (1949–1989). His work on the nineteenth century German Labour movement places him firmly in the mainstream tradition of Marxist–Leninist historical interpretation.^[2]

Life

Horst Bartel was born in Cottbus. His father worked in street construction. By the time Bartel left school, in 1942, war had broken out. Bartel started a teacher training course at Orlau in Upper Silesia, but he left the course in 1944 without completing it. In the meantime, in 1943 he joined the Hitler Youth organisation, and during the same year was conscripted for National Labour Service. As Germany's eastern frontier moved west to the accompaniment of industrial scale ethnic cleansing, he appears to have moved west, since in 1945 he was captured not by the Red army but by the Americans who held him as a prisoner of war between May and September 1945, initially at Heilbronn and subsequently at Linz.^[2]

Between September 1945 and 1946 Bartel worked as a messenger at a hospital in Cottbus. In April 1946 he was one of many thousands in what had by now become Germany's Soviet occupation zone to join the newly formed Socialist Unity Party of Germany (SED / Sozialistische Einheitspartei Deutschlands) which a few years later would become the ruling party for a new standalone "East German" state. Later the same year he embarked on a accelerated on-the-job teacher-training course^[3] The course included work as a teacher at a primary school at Peitz, a small town a short distance to the north of Cottbus. In Bartel's case, however, teaching was quickly superseded, still in 1946, by a period of university level study at Berlin's Humboldt University, focusing on History, German studies and Pedagogy. His student studies continued till 1949.^[2]

In 1949 Bartel became a teacher, and then a school head, in Wandlitz, just outside Berlin on its north side.^[2] Between July and September 1950 he then undertook a training course at the Regional Party Academy in Schmerwitz, before being an appointed, in 1951, Schools Advisor (Stadtschulrat) in the important Potsdam District. That same year he started a higher level study course at the Party Central Committee's Social Sciences Institute (Akademie für Gesellschaftswissenschaften beim ZK der SED / IfG). This led him to a doctorate, awarded in February 1956. The subject matter for his doctoral dissertation was the work of Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels for the newspaper, Der Sozialdemokrat during the period of the Anti-Socialist Laws (1878 - 1890).^[2]

Between 1956 and 1960 he worked as a lecturer, while at the same time heading up the teaching department at the IfG. In 1960, on the recommendation of Ernst Engelberg, Bartel took over as Director of The Institute. He was also appointed deputy director of the Historical Institute of the (East) German Academy of Sciences, an appointment made despite opposition from the Academy founder and well regarded economist Jürgen Kuczynski.^[5] From 1966 Bartel was also serving as Associate Professor with a teaching post and a professorial chair covering the History of the German Labour Movement at the important Party Central Committee's Social Sciences Institute / Academy (IfG/AfG).^[2][6]

From 1956 till 1959 Bartel was a member of the editorial collective on the "Journal for Historical Science" ("Zeitschrift für Geschichtswissenschaft"). He then joined the editorial collective of the academic journal "Contributions to the History of the German Labour Movement" ("Beiträge zur Geschichte der deutschen Arbeiterbewegung"), remaining with the journal till his death. Between 1967 and 1973 he was the Editor of the "History Yearbook" ("Jahrbuch für Geschichte"). A further academic followed in 1969 when he received his habilitation for a work entitled "A Study of Contributions to the History if the Implementation of Marxism in the German Labour Movement during the final third of the Nineteenth Century" ("Studie Beiträge zur Geschichte der Durchsetzung des Marxismus in der deutschen Arbeiterbewegung im letzten Drittel des 19. Jahrhunderts").^[7] It was also in 1969 (again in the teeth of opposition from Kuczynski and others) that he was appointed to succeed Ernst Engelberg as director of the Historical Institute at the German Academy of Sciences, a position he retained till his death in 1984.^[2]

Horst Bartel provided information to the Ministry for State Security as a "Gesellschaftlicher Mitarbeiter Sicherheit" (a professionally high ranking category of Informal Stasi collaborator).^[8] At the same time he served as deputy chairman of the National History Council. He became a corresponding fellow of the German Academy of Sciences in 1969, progressing to a full fellowship in 1972. From 1975 he chaired the German Democratic Republic section of the German-Soviet Historical Commission. It was in this capacity that in 1977 he undertook an extended study visit to Moscow, and in 1982 he became a foreign member of the Soviet Academy of Sciences (as it was then known). Also in 1982 he became an associate professor of the Humboldt University in Berlin.^[2]

Evaluation

Horst Bartel was one of an initially small minority of committed communists in the Soviet occupation zone of Germany (from 1949 the German Democratic Republic) at the end of the war who not merely worked together on constructing historical seminars and institutes, but together transformed the context of historical study so that it might comply with the precepts of the East German ruling Socialist Unity Party of Germany (SED / Sozialistische Einheitspartei Deutschlands).

Lothar Merthens, a prolific historian who was also noted as an uncompromising critic of the German Democratic Republic and its one party dictatorship, contended that Bartel, along with like-minded colleagues such as Walter Bartel, Karl Bittel, Rudolf Lindau and Albert Schreiner, lacked necessary academic competence, and that even within party corridors were widely viewed as simple propagandists.^[9]

Awards and honoours

• 1966 National Prize of East Germany 1st class for science and technology
• 1979 Patriotic Order of Merit in silver

References