Fatal Honeymoon

Fatal Honeymoon is a 2012 made-for-television movie directed and produced by Nadia Tass. It is said to be based on the true story of the suspicious death of Christina Mae "Tina" Watson (née Thomas), a twenty-six-year-old American on her honeymoon with David Gabriel "Gabe" Watson whilst scuba diving near the Great Barrier Reef, Queensland, Australia. However, the majority of the movie is not based on known facts from the evidence presented at the various trials or independent investigations.^[1]

Plot

Eleven days into their marriage, Alabama couple Gabe (Billy Miller) and Tina Watson (Amber Clayton) go scuba diving near Australia's Great Barrier Reef, where Tina drowns in what appears to be a freak accident. But her father Tommy (Harvey Keitel) begins to suspect that his daughter's death was by no means an accident, a belief shared by authorities in both America and Australia, including Detective Gary Campbell (Gary Sweet).

An investigation ensues, as does a media frenzy and a series of legal battles.^[2]

Cast

• Billy Miller as Gabe Watson
• Amber Clayton as Tina Watson
• Gemma Forsyth as Alanda McCarthy
• Gary Sweet as Detective Gary Campbell
• Harvey Keitel as Tommy Thomas
• Liz Alexander as Cindy Thomas
• Brad McMurray as Officer Hantz
• Amanda Muggleton as Glenda Watson
• Kate Jenkinson as Kim Watson

Marriage and Death of Tina Watson

See Main Article: Death of Tina Watson.

Release and Reception

It premiered in the United States on Lifetime on August 25 2012 and received a cinematic release in Australia in 2014.

Variety's Geoff Berkshire remarked that with 'its strict fidelity to genre cliches and steadfast focus on the true-crime formula, Fatal Honeymoon plays like warmed-over comfort food for armchair detectives. Not even the unexpected presence of Harvey Keitel is enough to distinguish the pic from any number of similar efforts.' He further criticised the lack of character depth in the film, commenting that writers Mac Gudgeon and Teena Booth 'seem more interested in dropping clunky references to scuba diving ... rather than providing the characters with any psychological depth or shading. There’s no sense that these stick figures trapped in a by-the-numbers melodrama could be real people swept up in tragic circumstances.

'There’s little for the actors to do other than go through the motions. Keitel has a few flashy scenes as a grieving father, but the largely dull role remains significantly below his skill level.' Technically, Berkshire concluded, the film is 'in line with low-budget telepic standards.'^[3]

David Hinckley, of the New York Daily News gave the film two out of five stars, praised the performances of Clayton and Miller, commenting that she 'suppresses what we know should be all her legitimate worries while Miller makes Gabe thoroughly unlikable at best and often downright sinister.' He surmised that men 'tend to be a miserable lot in Lifetime movies, most of them anyway, and it can make for tough viewing. ... In the end, “Fatal Honeymoon” seems vaguely unsatisfying — not because of its conclusion, but because it feels like an extended dramatization that in the end tells us less than a straight news report or documentary could have done. ... Whatever the truth, Gabe should go into Hallmark’s Male Villains Hall of Fame on the first ballot.' ^[4]

Many experienced scuba divers have expressed dissatisfaction with the movie based on claims made in the movie about diving. One of the defence's diving expert witnesses at the Alabama murder trial, Michael McFadyen, has stated that the movie bears little resemblance to what actually occurred and what witness statements say happened. ^[5]

References