Central Churchmanship

Part of a series on
Anglicanism
Theology
Christian theology Anglican doctrine Thirty-nine Articles Books of Homilies Caroline Divines Lambeth Quadrilateral Episcopal polity Sacraments Mary
Ministry and worship
Ministry Music Eucharist King James Version Book of Common Prayer Liturgical year Churchmanship High Low Central Broad Monasticism Saints
Christianity
Jesus Christ Paul Christian Church First seven Ecumenical Councils
Background and history
Celtic Christianity Augustine of Canterbury Bede Medieval cathedral architecture Henry VIII English Reformation Thomas Cranmer Dissolution of Monasteries Church of England Edward VI Elizabeth I Parker Hooker James I Charles I Laud Nonjuring schism Anglo-Catholicism Oxford Movement Homosexuality
Anglican Communion
Anglican Communion history Archbishop of Canterbury Anglican Communion Primates' Meetings Lambeth Conference Bishops Anglican Consultative Council Ecumenism Ordination of women Windsor Report
Continuing Anglicanism
Anglican realignment Bartonville Agreement Congress of St. Louis North American Anglican Conference
Anglicanism portal

Central Churchmanship describes those who adhere to the middle way in the Anglican Communion of the Christian religion, being neither markedly high church/Anglo-Catholic nor low church/evangelical Anglican in their liturgical preferences. The term is used much less frequently than some others. Cyril Garbett, Archbishop of York, uses the term along with Anglo-catholic, Liberal and Evangelical as a label for schools within the Church of England, but thirteen pages later states:

Within the Anglican Church are Anglo-Catholics, Evangelicals, Liberals and the great mass of English Churchmen who are content to describe themselves as Churchmen without any further label. (Garbett:13 & 26)

The term came into use in the late nineteenth century when traditional High Churchmen decided to distance themselves from Anglo-Catholicism and Ritualism(Chadwick:357)). Central Churchmen value both the official liturgies of the Church of England, which they clothe in a moderate amount of ceremonial and a characteristically Anglican way of doing theology that is rooted in the Bible, and the Councils and Creeds of the Early Church, whilst acknowledging the contribution made by the English Reformation. In their theological thinking they steer a middle course between the Anglo-Catholic and Evangelical parties,(MacGrath:112) both of which are perceived as being extreme by Central Churchmen. F. A. Iremonger places William Temple among this group emphasizing that Temple had a firm hold on the articles of the historic creeds and a conviction that what is best in each school of thought within the Church is worth conserving.(Iremonger:494)

Perhaps the best known exponent of the Central Churchman position in the twentieth century was Geoffrey Francis Fisher, Archbishop of Canterbury from 1945 to 1961. Many other well-known English bishops, including Robert Stopford, Henry Montgomery Campbell, and Mervyn Haigh also favoured a Central Churchmanship approach, as a way of defusing tensions within their dioceses, and as a way of promoting a "brand image" for the Church of England.

Since the 1970s Central Churchmanship as a distinct school of thought and practice within the Church of England has been in decline. This is mainly due to the closure or merger of some Theological Colleges that used to favour the Central position—namely, Wells Theological College, Lincoln Theological College, and Tenbury Wells—and a drift towards theological Liberalism, or Affirming Catholicism in others.

Overlap with "Broad Church"

Traditionally "Broad Church" has been used to refer to a particular tendency within Anglicanism which flourished in the 19th Century (Cross & Livingstone); however, it has recently been used as a virtual synonym for Central Churchmanship (Hylson-Smith:339) and it appears that this is fairly standard in the United States of America.

References

• Cross; Livingstone (eds.). "Broad Church". Oxford Dictionary of the Christian Church. London(1974): OUP. ODCC. 
• Chadwick, Owen. The Victorian Church (Part II). London: Adam & Charles Black(1972). 
• Garbett, Cyril(Archbishop of York). The Claims of the Church of England. London: Hodder&Stoughton(1947). 
• Hylson-Smith, Kenneth. High Churchmanship in the Church of England. Edinburgh: T&T Clark(1993). 
• Iremonger, F.A. William Temple. OUP(1948). 
• MacGrath, Alister. The Renewal of Anglicanism. SPCK(1993).